And buyers.
Not public art.
Art is organic. It doesn’t suddenly erupt. It’s a process. A struggle. And where do you find such conflict?
It could be anywhere. Where ideas about culture and society clash and compete for attention.
It’s not a sense of place, though place has its place. It’s a sense of feeling, mood and instinct.
Drawing a line and saying this is where art will gestate smacks of totalitarianism, of someone’s intense need to control and conduct.
There will be conditions. Who will decide what is art? Will a mural of a male couple kissing be appropriate? Or pass the test? Will a mural of the death and transfiguration of Christ adhere to standards set by someone?
That’s the problem – someone will decide what is appropriate. Someone will set standards. Someone will tell the artists that they can’t paint this or that.
Therein lies the rub.
In reality, designating an arts district runs counter to the instincts of most artists and performers.
You have created a boundary. Artists don’t like boundaries. They like freedom, independence, cheap food, cheap rent and a place to be left alone.
Creativity begs for freedom of expression.
Not window dressing.
Did the Rive Gauche in Paris make artists famous? Or did the artists, intellectuals, pimps, thieves and prostitutes make the Left Bank famous?
Was it the architecture? The cafes with sullen waiters? Or was it a feeling among the hundreds of people who congregated there, led by an intense desire to paint, exchange ideas, fornicate, drink cheap wine and eat cheap food.
This is so American.
We think that by drawing a line around a couple of city blocks we have created a milieu for artists and performers.
Prettify those battered blocks of concrete and the creative energy will burst forth upon the city scene.
No it won’t.
But I have something to confess.
I lived and breathed art. I was raised by artists. They fought, fornicated, struggled with the lows of poverty and the highs of recognition, ate when they could, argued and lived.
There were no tax incentives or rebates or arts districts.
Art wasn’t driven by city officials or a special interest group. It was driven by individuals with passion.
Art is an expression of the individual, not of a group and of group-think.
Underneath the tinsel, the gloss and the glamour, I suspect that something wicked this way comes.
Wow. That was beautiful. And refreshing. Thank-you.
ReplyDeleteI actually think this is something Norfolk needs. Even if it doesn't work - which, let's be honest, city hall will hose it up - at least we can say we tried. We need to do something and then we can keep improving it if we need.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comments.
ReplyDeleteFrom my partner, Hannah Serrano, for those looking for the rest of the story:
ReplyDeleteOh the joys of trying to do big/good things in Norfolk... Read a very interesting take on the proposed Norfolk Arts District in Veer Magazine this morning and wanted to say a couple things about it, since the reporter overlooked calling myself or Jesse, and seemingly anyone else who has actually been involved in trying to get this cause of the ground. So the first thing I just have to point out is the lazy reporting. I'm guessing since Michelle Washington actually did speak to both of us and City reps for her PilotOnline.com - The Virginian-Pilot article (http://hamptonroads.com/2013/01/quest-beauty), Newswanger didn't feel it pertinent to do his due diligence.
Second major thing I want to point out is that the caption under a picture of the Zedd's mural that we helped coordinate--one of which is the beautiful and whimsical piece by Elizabeth Cooke that I have as my FB cover photo--describes the artwork as "graffiti." If the work created by Cooke, and fellow artists Christopher Jude Ranes, Asa Jackson, and James Davis are in his eyes graffiti, then I can see why Newswanger might infer that a "parade of art and entertainment" could actually "offend" people and cause "customers [to] flee and never return." Otherwise the idea of artwork stirring that kind of fear in people is just CRAY-ZY. This is a neighborhood where a woman was recently robbed at knifepoint--now that's the kind of stuff that makes people not want to go somewhere. And we actually expect folks to travel to these blocks in their finest clothes for opera performances and Chrysler Museum events. I'm just shocked that the idea of adding artwork and better lighting would be bad for an area where the businesses actually "discourage clients from meeting at [their] office."
The third major thing I wanted to respond to is the article's mention of the change in zoning. Most of that work was happening before we even started talking about an arts district--see this article in the Atlantic about Frank Duke's work on the character districts: http://bit.ly/OPIK8S. The continued work that he has done has been for the benefit of the neighborhood's property owners, and I have personally sat in on meetings to which every owner in the district has been invited to voice their opinion on the changes in uses.
And the last thing that I wanted to respond to is the insinuation that this process might be happening "in a vacuum." We have worked diligently to reach out to every stakeholder that we can--including business leagues, civic leagues, artists, arts institutions, and City departments--and we continue to do so. And like Williamsburg's EDA, the City of Norfolk has also put together a committee to evaluate how the arts district can be developed and managed. Suppose if Newswanger had called up anyone from the City, he'd have known that.
But lastly, I want to say that this article doesn't piss me off as much as it would've when I was younger, greener, and more insistent that I live in a place where progress and big ideas are greatly met with encouragement. Everything worth doing will cause someone to tell you NOT to do it. That's what makes great work great. It took my hometown of Virginia Beach 10 freaking years to get on board with light rail and now they're all eating crow. I'm also a believer that no press is bad press--so thank you Veer and Philip Newswanger on the refreshing reminder that you can't do anything good around here without someone questioning why or how.
IN SUMMATION, PEOPLE OF NORFOLK: PUBLIC ART, FOOD TRUCKS, BIKE LANES AND THE LIKE WILL NOT DEVALUE THE PROPERTIES THAT SIT EMPTY ON OUR MAIN DRAG OR STEAL YOUR CUSTOMER BASE OR CAUSE MASS HYSTERIA ON THE STREETS. EVERYTHING WILL BE OK IF YOU JUST BREATHE AND HAVE A LITTLE COURAGE AND TRY THE THINGS THAT YOUR CITIZENS ARE ACTUALLY CALLING FOR. Oh, and I still love you. Thanks for reading.
Yo girl, chill out. It's just one person's opinion.
ReplyDeleteI used to be able to find good information from your content.
ReplyDeleteAlso visit my homepage: external hemorrhoid treatment
my site: natural hemorrhoid treatment
Ηеat Loс еrotic mаssаge Tops οut of Rіverѕiԁe,
ReplyDeleteCA has begun tο bе іnѕtalleԁ in your home.
Although not іdentical, Androiԁ skіn.
Here iѕ my blog tantra
This segment considers the plight from Native Americans.
ReplyDeleteWhen solid resources matter leaks to the cesspool, foul problems occur.
Feel free to surf to my website: prywatny detektyw warszawa